The Art of Rejection: Lessons From a First-Time Author’s Publishing Journey

As I sit down to reflect on my journey as a first-time author, the word "rejection" echoes in my mind like a haunting melody that I can't quite shake. Like many aspiring writers, I had dreams of sharing my stories with the world, but the path to publication is rarely a straight line. Instead, it resembles a winding road filled with unexpected twists, turns, and—most daunting of all—rejections.

Leaving California for a year-long adventure in Bali, Indonesia, I sought solace and inspiration to write my book, Confused Girl: Find Your Peace in the Chaos. The lush rice field and tranquil beaches became my creative sanctuary, allowing me to pour my heart into my manuscript. I returned to California during the COVID-19 pandemic, determined to find an agent who could help me share my work with the world.

After a diligent search, I secured representation with a reputable agent!

My excitement was palpable; I was finally on my way! But soon, the reality of the publishing world set in. One by one, I received rejections from various publishing companies. Each "no" felt like a personal blow, a validation of my deepest fears of inadequacy. I revised my book proposal time and time again, believing that each iteration would bring me closer to success. But instead, I encountered more rejections.

It was during this tumultuous period that I began to understand the art of rejection—not as a series of failures, but as an integral part of the creative process. I realized that, much like friendships and relationships, my creative projects also needed space to grow. Just as I wouldn’t suffocate a friendship with constant demands and expectations, I had to learn to let my book breathe.

So, I let it go. I decided that perhaps I hadn’t done everything I could do at that point. The only option left was to consider self-publishing. But then, life threw another curveball at me: my father was diagnosed with cancer. In the midst of my personal turmoil, I knew it wasn’t the right time to push forward with my book. I marked my calendar for two weeks after the new year in 2023, planning to discuss the possibility of taking back my proposal from my agent.

What happened next was nothing short of miraculous!

Just a few days into the new year, I received an email from my agent that made my heart race: a publishing company was interested in my book. My disbelief was overwhelming. Where were these people during the last 2.5 years?

But the surprises didn’t end there. Shortly after, another publisher expressed interest, leading to a bidding war for my book. I went from fearing that I would never get published to receiving multiple offers from reputable companies. It was a surreal experience that taught me the importance of patience and the necessity of giving my creative work the time it needed.

The Wisdom of Khalil Gibran

In reflecting on my book journey, I am reminded of the wisdom of Khalil Gibran, a Lebanese-American poet and philosopher known for his profound insights on love and life. In his work The Prophet, Gibran writes about love using the metaphor of a flower:

"If you love a flower, don’t pick it. For the moment you pluck it from the earth, it will begin to wither, losing the very beauty that captivated you in the first place."

This beautiful sentiment encapsulates the essence of allowing things—whether relationships, experiences, or creative projects—to exist in their natural state without interference. When we attempt to possess or control something we love, we may inadvertently destroy it.

Giving Space for Growth

This metaphor resonates deeply with my experience as a writer. Just as Gibran advises against picking a flower, I learned that my creative projects, too, needed space to breathe, grow, and evolve without my constant control and desperation. When I initially faced rejection, my instinct was to cling tighter to my work, revising and resubmitting in a cycle of anxiety. However, I found that by stepping back and allowing my manuscript to rest, I could gain clarity and perspective.

In the same way that a flower blooms in its own time, so too does a creative project flourish when given the room to develop. The act of letting go—of allowing my book to exist outside of my immediate grasp—proved transformative. It allowed me to return with fresh eyes, renewed energy, and an understanding that timing is crucial.

Tips for Mastering Rejection

• Accept the Process: Understand that rejection is a natural part of the creative journey. Every author, artist, and creator has faced it. Accepting this reality can help you develop resilience.
• Revise and Reflect: Use rejection as an opportunity for growth. Each "no" can provide valuable feedback. Take time to revise your work, reflect on the feedback, and grow stronger as a creator.
• Give It Space: Just as friendships need room to breathe, so do your creative projects. Allow your work to sit for a while. This distance can provide fresh perspectives and new ideas.
• Cultivate Patience: Timing is everything. Often, what feels like a setback can turn into a blessing in disguise. Be patient with the process, and trust that your moment will come.
• Find Support: Surround yourself with a community of fellow creatives who understand the challenges of rejection. Sharing your experiences can provide comfort and motivation. You can start right now in the Stage 32 Lounges!
• Keep Going: The only way to guarantee failure is to give up. Keep writing, keep submitting, and keep believing in your work. Persistence pays off.
• Celebrate Small Wins: Even the smallest progress deserves recognition. Celebrate every step, whether it’s finishing a chapter, submitting a proposal, or simply getting through a tough day. Have you joined in on Stage 32's November Write Club yet? It's happening all month and is a great way to set goals for yourself and celebrate your progress! You can learn how to join in HERE.
• Trust Your Path: Remember that every author has a unique path. Your journey may not look like anyone else's, but it’s yours to own and cherish.

As I reflect on the last few years, I’m grateful for the lessons that rejection has taught me. It has shaped me not only as a writer but as a person. The pain of rejection has made the joy of acceptance all the more sweet.

I’ve come to understand that mastering the art of rejection isn’t about becoming immune to it. Instead, it’s about learning to navigate through the highs and lows, trusting the process, and allowing your creativity the space to flourish.

So, to all the aspiring authors out there facing rejection: remember that you are not alone. Accept where you are, learn from every setback, and trust that your moment will come. In the end, the art of rejection is just one step on the path to becoming the author you were always meant to be.

Let's hear your thoughts in the comments below!

Got an idea for a post? Or have you collaborated with Stage 32 members to create a project? We'd love to hear about it. Email Ashley at blog@stage32.com and let's get your post published!

Please help support your fellow Stage 32ers by sharing this on social. Check out the social media buttons at the top to share on Instagram @stage32 , Twitter @stage32 , Facebook @stage32 , and LinkedIn @stage-32 .